4 Ways to Use Your Impact Report to Market a Fundraiser

August 20, 2024

In the nonprofit world, it’s not uncommon to hear organizations speak in platitudes when describing the positive impact they’re having on those they serve. A few phrases that often get tossed around include: 

• Truly making a difference
• Changing lives for the better 
• Working toward a better tomorrow 

You may have used language like this yourself, and for good reason. It’s nice shorthand that indicates your nonprofit is doing important work. 

However, to give a full picture of how and why your organization is making a difference, changing lives, or creating a better tomorrow, you need impact information to back up your claims. This is where having an impact measurement strategy comes in handy.  

What is impact measurement? 

Impact measurement is the process of evaluating the effectiveness of your nonprofit’s programs, initiatives, and projects to better understand the impact of your operations on the communities you serve. Typically, this involves using an online platform to gather data and track your progress toward the smaller objectives that will help you one day achieve your larger vision. 

Impact Reports 

Many nonprofits summarize their impact measurement insights in an impact report. According to UpMetrics, this is “a document that gives an overview of a mission-driven organization’s outcomes and achievements, focusing on the social, economic, or environmental effects of the organization’s work.” Within the report, you’ll showcase the quantitative and qualitative data that serve as evidence for the impact you’re making on your community. 

Your impact report can be a useful resource for promoting your mission and marketing specific initiatives, like fundraising campaigns, whether you’re adapting its information into a series of social media posts or letting it serve as the basis for conversations with your major donors. 

Let’s dive into some specific ways you can use an impact report to market your nonprofit’s fundraisers. 

1. Showcase the quantifiable results of your work. 

Imagine your nonprofit focuses on serving refugee families in your local area. Which of the following statements sounds more compelling to you? 

• Last month, we donated many hygiene kits to refugee families in the Bay Area. 
• Last month, we donated 8,560 hygiene kits to refugee families in the Bay Area, a record number for our organization!

Clearly, the second statement stands out. This is because the specific metric of 8,560 kits provides an image your audience can picture—thousands of kits being given to families in need. The additional information about the number of kits being a record for your organization puts the number into context, providing perspective about just how big of an accomplishment this is.  

Quantifiable impact insights like this provide clear, objective evidence of your organization’s achievements. They appeal to your audience’s logic and can easily be communicated in several ways. 

For instance, with the example above, you could easily design a bar graph image that shows growth in the number of donated hygiene kits over time. Or, you might include this information in a larger infographic that provides an overview of everything the organization has done for refugee families in the last year. 

For more tips and tricks check out: 5 Tips (With Examples) for Using Statistics to Tell a Story.

2. Share compelling success stories. 

Sometimes cold, hard numbers aren’t enough to catch a supporter’s eye and get them thinking about giving to your fundraising campaign. That’s where stories come into play. 

Stories can help to illustrate your impact in a way that appeals to your audience’s emotions, adding color and depth to quantified insights. This is why, when measuring your impact, it’s important not to overlook the importance of gathering qualitative data, like testimonials, interviews, and even photos or videos. 

For instance, say your organization held interviews with several refugees who received your hygiene kits. Getting their perspective on your organization’s work and how it’s helping to improve their quality of life can be a powerful way to show your donors the importance of your efforts. 

If you’re interested in improving your nonprofit storytelling abilities, try these tips: 

• Be descriptive, relying on the five senses to provide the details that make your audience feel immersed in the story. 

• Use engaging visuals, like pictures of your team at work or your beneficiaries receiving your services.

• Incorporate a call to action to encourage your audience to contribute to your organization’s efforts to continue making an impact.  

3. Use impact data as a complement to personalized messages. 

The best way to make a donor feel that their individual contribution is essential to the success of your fundraising campaign is to personalize your marketing messages and your donation asks. 

Here are a few ways to do so: 

• Address donors by their preferred names instead of using something generic like “Dear Valued Donor.” 

• Reference past contributions or involvement. 

• Ask donors for a donation amount that fits their current giving level and capacity. 

You can take your personalization efforts even further by incorporating impact data into your messages. Showing the role that your donors played in past achievements can inspire them to contribute to your work again. 

Here are a few examples of what this might look like: 

• Thanks to your donation last month, we were able to outfit three refugee children with all of the school supplies they’ll need for this academic year.

• Donors like you helped us build five new homes for refugee families next year. Can you help us do more this year? 

• Because you gave $50 last November, you helped us provide holiday meals for 10 refugee families. This year, would you be willing to give $100?

This strategy helps connect the dots for donors. By pointing out exactly what their donations do for your cause, you’re demonstrating that their dollars can have a tangible impact on the beneficiaries you both want to serve. 

4. Point out needs and areas for improvement. 

Impact reports won’t just highlight the good your nonprofit has done. They’ll also point out where your nonprofit needs support or what its future focus areas should be. 

Including your most pressing needs, and yes, even your past shortcomings, in your impact report allows you to be more transparent with your supporters. That spirit of transparency can then carry over into your campaign marketing, empowering you to show your supporters how you plan to improve and how they can help.  

For instance, say that your nonprofit notices that enrollment is down in its English as a Second Language (ESL) courses for adult refugees and that beneficiaries are reporting in surveys that more classes need to be offered on weekends. Having this information allows you to address the issues with the ESL program and tailor it to better meet your beneficiaries’ needs. It also gives you a talking point for getting more support for the program from your donors. 

For instance, you might be able to post a beneficiary’s story on your Instagram profile, where the individual’s son explains that their mother needs to learn English to find a better job that supports her family. In the caption of your post, you could explain that you’re actively making improvements to the ESL program to help families like this and issue a call to action for your followers to donate to help these changes happen faster.  

Being transparent and genuine like this will help strengthen your donor relationships and will help your organization appear more authentic and human, sparking a desire in your supporters to help fund your work. 

---

Measuring your impact allows you to get a full picture of how your organization affects the people it serves and empowers you to market your fundraising efforts more effectively as you demonstrate what is possible when your donors support your work. 

Use the strategies above to infuse your next marketing push with impact insights and inspire more support!